Advocacy

Technology Transition Rule Questions & Answers

November 7, 2023 | 9 minute read

Below are answers to the questions asked during the October 27, 2023 webinar (full webinar is available here). In addition to the below questions, the EPA has also put together a list of frequent questions.

Residential and Commercial Cooling (Air Conditioning and Heat Pumps)

Please note any reference to air conditioning also applies to heat pumps in the context of the EPA-published rule.

Products


Q: Would commercial rooftop or residential package units qualify as a product with a three-year sell-through date?
A: Yes, package equipment’s refrigerant components come fully self-contained and ready for use from the factory.


Q: Manufacturers must stop producing commercial rooftop package units using high-GWP refrigerants after January 1, 2025, but distributors can continue to sell R-410A rooftop package units until January 1, 2028?
A: Yes, the three-year sell-through begins on the manufacturing cutoff date, allowing distributors, manufacturers, and installers to sell products until January 1, 2028.


Q: Does the three-year sell-through start from January 1, 2025, or the manufacture date?
A: The three-year sell-through begins on January 1, 2025, and goes until January 1, 2028.


Q: Do water source heat pumps qualify under "product" category with a three-year sell-through?
A: As long as the equipment’s refrigerant-containing components are self-contained in the unit and comes pre-charged from the factory, it is considered a product with a three-year sell-through.


Q: Isn't there an export prohibition starting 1/1/2025?
A: No, the export prohibition on products begins on January 1, 2028, the same cutoff date for the product sell-through. This means any products remaining in inventory on January 1, 2028, cannot be sold, distributed, or exported after that date.


Systems


Q: What if a project is installing indoor units in 2024, but the outdoor units are installed in 2025?
A: This would be considered an illegal install by the published rule. Part of the EPA’s definition of installation is to “complete the refrigerant circuit,” therefore EPA would not consider the unit installed until 2025.


Q: In new construction, does the unit have to be charged before 1/1/2025, or just the lines connected?
A: EPA defines install as “to complete a field-assembled system’s [refrigerant] circuit, including charging with a full charge, such that the system can function and is ready for use for its intended purpose.” The refrigerant lines would need to be connected and the system fully charged by January 1, 2025.


Q: Does it matter who does the "install?" For example, can a homeowner install a DIY system, but a professional HVAC/R person could not?
A: No, full system installation is prohibited by anyone past January 1, 2025.

Q: Is the install date regulation final? Any possibility of an argument to change the date?
A: The rule was published in the Federal Register on October 24, 2023, making it law. Any changes must be done through a future rulemaking process that can take time to complete.


Q: Does Puerto Rico follow the same install date?
A: Yes, the Technology Transition Rule and all AIM Act rules apply to Puerto Rico and other U.S. territories.


VRF/VRV


Q: Could a Multi-Zone Mini-Split be defined as VRF/VRV system?
A: EPA separates VRF/VRV from multi-split by requiring that an air-source VRF/VRV unit be above 65,000 Btus, and the system needs a variable-capacity compressor capable of operating at least three different capacities. Here is the full definition from the EPA: Variable refrigerant flow/variable refrigerant volume systems. These are engineered DX multi-split systems incorporating the following: a split system air conditioner or heat pump incorporating a single refrigerant circuit that is a common piping network to two or more indoor evaporators, each capable of independent control, or compressor units. VRF systems contain a single module outdoor unit or combined module outdoor units with at least one variable capacity compressor that has three or more steps of capacity, with air or water as the heat source. In response to comment below, we clarify that air-source VRF systems have capacities of 65,000 BTU/h (19 kW) or more, while water-source VRF systems can be of any capacity.


Mini-Split AC/HP


Q: Ductless that is not VRF/VRV but traditional mini-splits fall into the 1/1/2025 prohibition, correct?
A: Yes, ductless mini-splits are a system with a January 1, 2025, install prohibition based on the published rule.


Q: Do mini-split air conditioners and heat pump units have a sell-through?
A: Under the published rule, there is no sell-through for the full mini-split system; however, components such as the indoor evaporator unit and the outdoor condensing unit, along with any parts such as compressors or pre-charged line sets, can be replaced after January 1, 2025.


Q: Can a technician replace an indoor coil while leaving the outdoor, or is mini-split always considered a system?
A: Individual components, such as the indoor coil, can be replaced after January 1, 2025. Components include the indoor evaporator unit, outdoor condensing unit, and any parts such as compressors or pre-charged line sets. Both the indoor evaporator unit and the outdoor condensing unit cannot be changed at the same time.


Q: Would a single-phase, heat pump multi-zone mini-split system qualify as a VRF/VRV or as a split system?
A: Mini-splits would be a split system, VRF/VRV systems have a minimum size and variable capacity requirements and use two or more indoor evaporators.


Components


Q: Can you replace the indoor evaporator coil and outdoor condensing unit as long as the air handler/furnace isn't changed?
A: No, EPA’s system definition does not include the air handler or furnace. EPA limits its system definition to refrigerant-containing components; if both the indoor evaporator coil and outdoor condensing units are replaced, that is considered a system installation, not a component replacement, and is prohibited after January 1, 2025, for AC and heat pumps.


Q: If I had an existing R-410A unit that needed a new evaporator coil and condensing unit but not a furnace, would I be required to replace everything?
A: The furnace would not have to be replaced with the evaporator and condensing units; EPA does not consider the furnace/air-handler part of the refrigerant-containing system.


Q: What if the replacement is just an indoor evaporator coil or air-handling unit?
A: Replacing the indoor evaporator unit, with or without changing the air-handling unit, and leaving the existing outdoor condensing unit in place is considered a component replacement/repair and is allowed after January 1, 2025.


Q: Can repair trigger a "new" system?
A: A repair only triggers a new system installation if the indoor evaporator coil and the outdoor condensing unit are replaced simultaneously.


Q: Can manufacturers still produce 410A components (ex. condensers) past 1/1/2025?
A: Yes, equipment manufacturers are permitted to continue producing components, including outdoor condensing and indoor evaporator units for high-GWP refrigerants, including R-410A, past January 1, 2025.


Q: Is there a manufacture or import date restriction for R-410A outdoor condenser units used as components?
A: No, the published rule does not limit the manufacture or import of outdoor condensing units to be used as components after January 1, 2025.


Commercial Refrigeration

Components


Q: Would the component concept also apply to commercial refrigeration? Saying could a R-404A condensing unit be replaced as a component forever?
A: There is no regulatory deadline to stop replacing components in commercial refrigeration, however, as the supply of virgin refrigerants decreases due to the HFC phase-down, the cost of R-404A could cause an economic reason for replacing the system.


Q: Specific to commercial refrigeration on an existing walk-in cooler, a contractor could replace a failed condensing unit (component) on an R404A system. If six months later, the evaporator fails, he can then replace that evaporator (component) and continue to operate the existing R-404A system, and this cycle can continue indefinitely. Is this a correct interpretation?
A: Yes, here is EPA’s answer to a similar question: “Systems may be repaired over time. Factors for homeowners to consider when deciding to repair or transition to a new system using a lower-GWP refrigerant include availability of components, energy efficiency, and total maintenance costs.”


Q: Can repair trigger a "new" system?A: A repair only triggers a new system installation if both the evaporator coil and the condensing unit are replaced at the same time.


Products


Q: Does the three-year sell-through start from January 1, 2025 or the manufacture date?
A: The three-year sell-through begins on January 1, 2025, and goes until January 1, 2028.


Q: Isn't there an export prohibition starting 1/1/2025?
A: No, the export prohibition on products begins on January 1, 2028, the same cutoff date for the product sell-through. This means any products remaining in inventory on January 1, 2028, cannot be sold, distributed, or exported after that date.


General Questions


Q: Is HARDI planning to file a legal challenge to the January 2025 sell-through prohibition for residential split systems?
A: We continue to exhaust every avenue and alternative to legal action but a total lack of sell-through for residential split-system equipment is an unacceptable situation for our members and the industry. HARDI is working with the EPA and our industry allies to find a solution that maintains the goals of the Technology Transition Rule and protects the HVACR supply chain.


Q: What liability does the distributor or manufacturer have when the contractor installs an R-410a system past the allowed date?
A: From the EPA’s frequent questions: “Original equipment manufacturers and distributors of components are typically not responsible for the installation of the equipment that they sell. Generally speaking, the responsible party would be the company that installs or directs the installation of the system. This may be different for complex and custom-designed refrigeration, air conditioning, and heat pump systems such as supermarkets and industrial process refrigeration if the distributor or original equipment manufacturer is involved in the design of the system.”


Q: Is this session being recorded and will it be shared with attendees?
A: Yes, it is available here.


Q: Will online retailers be held to the same rules as the brick and mortar?
A: Yes, the Technology Transition rule is equally applied to both online and in-person purchases.


HARDI's Congressional Fly-In

May 21-22, 2024

HARDI Members - Join us in Washington, DC where we brief you on policies that matter, arrange meetings with representatives, and you get face-to-face with your representatives to affect policy change.

(REGISTER HERE)

Alex Ayers
Vice President of Government Affairs
Alex is HARDI’s lead lobbyist and regulatory expert, with over a decade of experience in Washington, DC. A former Iowa caucus delegate, he built early roots in grassroots politics. He has lobbied, published, and testified on taxes, energy, environment, agriculture, and economics. His work has been cited by the Wall Street Journal, Forbes, and the Tax Foundation.
Areas of Expertise
  • HVACR Policy
  • Government Affairs
  • Political Policy
2026-11-04 website-ad hardi 9pm-two-frames 300x250 v4 draftNew Platform - HARDI - November 2026
HARDI