Supply Chain & Operations

Top 5 Board Governance Q&A's from HARDI Annual Conference

January 8, 2020 | 5 minute read

Last month at Annual Conference, Jim Crocker presented "Why the Most Successful Companies all Have Boards of Directors" and "Strategic Planning and the Board of Directors". From these sessions, Jim rounded up the top 5 questions he received from members, and has answered them here for you today.


1. What’s the difference between a governance Board and an advisory Board?

There are three Board types: advisory Board, operating Board and governance Board.

Advisory boards don’t have any governance responsibility. Their purpose is solely to provide perspective and expertise that helps the business run better. In many cases, that’s all business owners are seeking. 

Operating Boards run the business. They make all the key decisions about how the organization will operate. The majority of North American private businesses have operating Boards. It’s common for Directors on an operating Board to have both governance and operating titles - for example, Board Chair and CEO. It’s also possible to have both an advisory Board and an operating Board. 

Governance Boards provide objective oversight of how the business is being operated. Their role is to ensure the business stays viable and successful by measuring risk, setting the strategic direction and holding the management team accountable for execution. The biggest difference between operating Boards and governance boards is role – oversight vs operations, and Board composition – governance Boards tend to be much more independent than operating Boards.

Hybrid operating/governance Boards are increasingly common in private business. Many owners recognize the value of objective expertise on their Board and are adding independent Directors to work with them at Board level.

2. How big should a Board be?

If a Board is too small, it risks having insufficient expertise to govern and/or operate effectively. Boards with only three people are likely too small.

If a Board is too large, it risks becoming unwieldy and a challenge to lead effectively. Observations suggest that anything over ten people is getting to that size. A Board is definitely too large when it strikes an Executive Committee to take over some of the Board’s governance responsibilities. 

Ideal Board size is typically between five and nine Directors. 

3. Should Directors be compensated?

We observe greater Board effectiveness when Directors are compensated. Although there are many wonderful volunteer Boards and Directors (many NFP’s could not survive without them), we observe that Directors who are compensated view their Board relationships differently. Typically they are more objective.  

Amount of compensation is always a concern. However, the amount of compensation is generally less important than the principle of being compensated, particularly in smaller companies. As a result, how much a Director is compensated merely needs to be viewed as fair by everyone. What’s fair will be different in a struggling start-up versus a multi-billion dollar conglomerate. 

Note that even on an advisory Board it’s fair for advisors to expect some kind of recognition of their contribution. However, the recognition need not be monetary. A nice meal or other perk is quite common. 

4. How do I bring an outsider onto by Board/into my business?

This is perhaps the greatest concern private business owners and leaders have about forming a governance Board. It’s a struggle to see how outsiders might help – “no one from the outside will ever know my business like I do”; and, there is a fear of losing control – “I would never take direction from somebody else on my business”.  

Both are legitimate concerns. The way to overcome them is to think clearly about who those outsiders are and the role they will play. 

First, no organization should/would bring just any outsider onto their Board.  Boards are moving to become more ‘competency-based’. What that means is that each Director clearly brings an expertise/knowledge/competency to the Board that is consistent with the risks and strategies the organization is facing. For example, many Boards are attracting experts with technology and cyber-risk backgrounds because their current Directors lack expertise in this critical area.

Second, private businesses are not public companies. Pure governance Boards (where the Board has the power to hire and fire the CEO) are unusual in private companies. In a private business, it’s simple for owners to achieve almost all of the benefits of a strong governance Board - help overseeing risk, developing strategy, measuring execution - without giving up any control of the organization. The way to achieve this to make it clear from the outset what the role and authority of the Board will be.  

5. What is the Board’s role in strategic planning?

Most governance Boards are ill-suited to develop the strategic plan. They lack the time, first-hand knowledge of the business and sometimes, even the necessary skills. Generally, Boards are much better suited to validate a plan proposal that is brought to them, and then approve it.  

Typically the plan proposal is developed by the leadership team. They have the time, proximity to the business and (hopefully) the skills. 

Validating the plan proposal is an important form of governance oversight. At times Boards will engage their own experts to ensure what’s being proposed is valid.

Once the Board approves the plan it becomes theirs. The Board is now responsible for ensuring the plan is well executed. Execution is led by the CEO and it is the Board’s responsibility to measure both plan execution and the CEO for performance. By staying on top of plan execution, Boards help ensure that organizations stay focused on the direction that everyone agreed was best for achieving the goals of the organization.  


Session Slides:
Strategic Planning and the Board of Directors
Why the Most Successful Companies All Have Boards of Directors

Jim Crocker
Chair, Boardroom Metrics
2026-11-04 website-ad hardi 9pm-two-frames 300x250 v4 draftNew Platform - HARDI - November 2026
HARDI
Top 5 Board Governance Q&A's from HARDI Annual Conference