Supply Chain & Operations

Making Sense of M&A: How to Prepare as a Buyer

March 18, 2022 | 13 minute read

Throughout the year, I will be leaning on my M&A consulting experience to provide a point of view on pertinent topics to our industry. Areas I intend to explore are below. If there are others you would like to see, please let me know.  
- Zachary Perge
”
  • How to prepare as a buyer

  • Contractor M&A: How to protect your market share

  • How to compete for acquisitions

  • How to increase valuations

  • Legal and regulatory concerns

  • M&A Alternatives

  • How do Investors evaluate wholesalers

  • How to execute Day 1 and integrate

  • What can go wrong 

  • Any other topics members feel are important!

Below I will explore a highly relevant topic: How to Prepare as a Buyer (which also provides a great insight to sellers). Even if this does not apply to your business, I aim to provide context that sheds light overall on the M&A landscape for our industry. There are countless ways to go out this process and this is meant to be directional. As a HARDI member you have access to the Distributor Performance Dashboards tool, which is essential to the valuation process. If you have specific questions, I am always here for you. I also highly recommended reading my piece on How to Prepare as a Seller which gives great context on the other side and is the ying to the yang of this information. 


1. Identify your Why.

Just because you can buy a company doesn’t always mean you necessarily should. Though there are ways to properly execute a sale, it is never without a massive amount of planning and work. There are a multitude of reasons WHY you may want to acquire a company. Ensure that the WHY you are looking to buy a company outweighs the CAN. Some common reasons for the WHY include:

  • New products and services that the target organization offers that you do not.

  • Brand equity, loyalty, reputation, and recognition of the organization.

  • Key customers of the organization.

  • Talent (sales, marketing, HR, leadership, etc).

  • Profitability/ net worth.

  • Geographic footprint.

  • Supplier relationships.

  • Favorable interest rates to take advantage of.

  • Maximizing your current financing situation.

  • Acquiring a distressed asset.

  • Believing you can optimize an underperforming organization.

  • Synergies between your businesses.

  • Acquiring established plant, property, equipment.

2. Conduct an Honest Assessment.

This is related identifying your why, but these are some high level questions you should ask yourself very early in the process.

  • Are we positive this will enhance our business? Have an extremely detailed vision for what the acquisition will do for your business and how it will impact future performance. The statistics on successful acquisitions are not pretty. 

  • Can we achieve some of these goals internally? Said another way, do we think we can execute some of the goals with our current resources as opposed to spending the money elsewhere. This is a personal example, but years ago I worked on a brand that spent a fortune on a niche brand in our space. We were floored as we all felt that given the time and direction, we could have developed as similar brand that was as good if not better than what we acquired. Ensure that you feel you’ve reached the limits of what you can currently accomplish.

  • Do we need a full blown acquisition? There are other measures short of a purchase you can engage in such as mergers, joint ventures, franchising, licensing, capital formation, or buying spinoff aspects of an organization (certain locations, facilities, brands, etc)

  • How are we going to pay for this? There are many ways to skin this cat, but you want to explore all options. Here are some possibilities

    • Use your own cash. Simple enough, right? You have total control over situation with no third party influence, but there are downsides. All the risk is on you, there is a finite amount of money and there are ALWAYS unforeseen costs that creep in in an acquisition that tie up internal capital investment.

    • Borrow the money. With interest rates quite low, this is part of the reason there has been such a flurry of M&A in every industry. However, you are beholden to the terms of the borrower and the hoops you have to jump through.

    • Private Equity Firms. If you are unwilling or (gulp) unable to secure funds from a bank, some PE firms are willing to jump in. This can come with a considerable amount of controlling interest. A benefit is that PE firms often can be a great resource for optimizing performance and have a very vested interest in making the acquisition a success. 

  • Do you have the appetite for the work that comes along with seeking sellers, going through the purchase, and handling integration? Acquiring a company is a ton of work, even if you work with outside help. Deals fall through, market dynamics change, emotions can get in the way, the diligence portion is grueling, etc. Most importantly, M&A work takes resources away from running your core business. It is almost ALWAYS requires more time than people initially think. (In a future post I’ll go deep on integration), but be honest with yourself in terms of what you can take on. 

  • Do we have a plan in place if an unexpected opportunity pops up? Often deals pop out of nowhere. An organization in the industry or a PE firm may unexpectedly will contact you and present with you a buying opp (often with a tight timetable). Do you have the ability to spring into action to evaluate and make the deal? There should be no half measures with a decision this big, so in your assessment, test your readiness to execute something unexpected should it come up. 

3. Assemble your team.

Full disclosure, some of this is lifted from my How to Prepare as a Seller, but it applies here as well. Depending on the size and complexity of your deal, some of these are nice to have, and some of these are needs to have.

  • Trusted internal team. Those within your organization that can help you prepare while also executing their everyday tasks and maintain confidentiality. When you are reviewing the marketing plan of an org, have you marketing personnel look at it. When going through the IT of a company, run it by your IT folks to see if it can fit and what would cost if it doesn’t. Review their comp & benefits with your comp & benefits folks, etc. Ultimately, they are the ones that will have to integrate and can spot red flags the best.

  • Investment banker/ financial advisor. He or she can help understand your situation, identify sellers, evaluate offers, structure the deal, and many other useful actions.

  • Legal. Even if you have an in-house lawyer, it may be useful to have outside council as you prepare to sell and draft the LOI (Letter of Intent). Often there are investment bankers and lawyers that work in tandem.

  • CPA. A need to have in terms of reviewing financial statements, tax implications, estate planning, etc.

  • Consultants. Several big firms can provide many of the services mentioned above. I speak from experience here, being a former M&A consultant, that the right firms provide incredible value and can meet any timeline you can dream up but come at a very high price. The value comes in the form of having experts in every single function of your business, loads of experience, and infinite benchmark data.

4. Due Diligence

Once you’ve identified your why, done internal assessments and chosen your team, the most important part begins; due diligence. Even more so than integration planning, this will be your most arduous step in the process.  In our industry, there is a great deal of familiarity between businesses, but do not let that prevent you from combing through every aspect of diligence. Diligence is a financial, legal, strategic, and cultural review of potential sellers. Grab your caffeinated beverage of choice/ sit somewhere comfortable as I will spend a good amount of time on this crucial topic. (I didn’t want to break this out as a separate section as I feel it’s important to assimilate into the large mosaic of the Buyer process. If you’d like to delve deeper into this, I’m happy to discuss 1 on 1.) Below are some key considerations for your due diligence work.

PREPARATION
  • How long you should you spend on diligence? Some will say max 60 days. Some will say max 90 days. I say it takes as long as it takes. A great quote on the subject by Andrew Sherman is “due diligence is a process, not an event”. Outline what you want to accomplish, not how long it will take to complete. 

  • The process should begin immediately after sending the Letter of Intent or agreement to explore terms.

  • Clearly layout expectations of what the expectations are for diligence; meeting frequency, key contacts, what will be shared, confidentiality, etc. Diligence falls apart if both parties aren’t committed to process. Also, it is important to walk the tightrope of being thorough without acting like a hostile IRS agent or intrusive detective.

  • An important discussion point pertains to cost. It is much more expensive to be the buyer than the seller. You pay for your lawyers, bankers, consultants, travel, etc. They pay for theirs. 

  • Establish a clean room (sometimes called a data room). This is a secure digital space where files are shared and kept that has limited access and detailed records of what is checked in and out and when and by who. If you are going old school, ensure you are given a secure physical working space with everything you need. 

WHAT TO EXPLORE
  • Corporate info. Articles of incorporation, annual reports, 10k, bylaws, reports, contact lists, partner firms, shareholders, etc. This is the table stakes info. 

  • Financials. Credit/ loan agreements, debts, audits, tax returns, federal filings, financial statements, budgets, inventory, accounts receivables, projections, income statement/ balance sheet/ cash flow. This is often the heaviest lift to receive and analyze. Ideally you want years upon years of this info. It is helpful to set expectations very early and very clearly as to what you expect to avoid one off requests for it. Even with GAAP, financials can be all over the place; highly complex, very sloppy, bare bones. If you don’t feel you and your team have the capabilities to analyze and act on these materials, it is worth it to bring in someone who can. Also, have very clearly metrics going in as to what you are looking for from these financials. If they don’t hit them, be prepared to walk away or change your asking price. 

  • Operations. Products, PPE, software, rebates, payment terms, leases, tangible assets, liens, patents, trademarks, fixed assets, charities, cybersecurity. It is common in our industry for family trusts or individuals to own the real estate. This can be a bit on an entanglement that commands special attention within the due diligence and closing process. 

  • Sales and Marketing Info. Customer lists, supply/ service agreements, market research, marketing campaigns past-present-future, competitors, sales incentives. 

  • Employee Info. Employee agreements, contacts, org chart, OSHA files, benefits, severance plans, ESOP, resumes, employee reviews/ files. 

  • Litigation and Claims. All litigation, proceedings, and arbitration. Any threatened claims, injunctions, or crimes.

  • Insurance. Policies, schedule, providers, rates.

  • Environmental Reports. Inspections, complaints, policies, hazardous substances, disposal policies, permits, commitments. 

  • Culture. Last but certainly not least is culture. Everything I’ve listed thus far can be documented. Culture cannot. Though metrics like turnover are essential, culture is never black and white. Large consulting shops have developed and use highly sophisticated programs that take survey inputs and metrics to determine compatibility. If you are considering a consulting shop, this is something to inquire about. Short of this, talk to everyone in their orbit; employees past and present from the C suite to maintenance staff, talk to suppliers, neighbors, competitors, vendors, community leaders. Talk to anyone that will talk to you. In my opinion M&A activity fails most frequently because of culture. If everything in the previous bullet points look great, but the company operates culturally completely differently, it can stop you from achieving your goals. 

This is another personal example, but for one transaction I encountered, everything was a relatively good fit on paper, but there was one odd sticking point; the company being acquired had an unlimited vacation policy. The acquiring company had a very rigid policy that allotted for very few days off annually.  The buyer believed this was something that shouldn’t preclude the deal from happening. It ended up being a disaster. The terms were that the acquired company would fall under the policy of the purchasing company. The employees from the purchased company revolted. To them, this was a benefit they expected and had planned their personal lives around. For many, it was perk a that attracted them to the company when joining. Several key employees threatened to leave as a result of the change. The buying company explored keeping the policy in place for a year for the acquired employees, much to the ire of their own employees, which felt that was unfair. Ultimately the acquiring company eradicated the policy, bringing the new group under their terms and lost employees. It was also a very bad tone for the integration. This is a cautionary tale in the sense EVERY aspect has to be considered during diligence. Keep in mind when a company is for sale, you will essentially get their dating profile; a curated image of their best traits.  Due diligence is meticulous process of sifting through the good, the bad, and the ugly.

5. Structure the Deal.

Congratulations if you’ve made it this far in the process! There are thousands of ways deals can be structured, too many for me to attempt to outline. Your goal should be to make it as simple to possible. With that in mind, here are the core aspects every deal should have;

  • Confirm names, addresses, serial numbers.

  • Determine price, date, and location.

  • Confirming financing terms.

  • “Reps and Warranties” (Promises from Seller, Promises from Buyer, Promises from Both).

  • Indemnifications. Essentially one side providing security against the loss from the other side. 

  • How a breach is handled.

  • Exhibits and Schedules. This is the minutia of the deal. These are the hundreds of things involved in the transaction such as Escrow agreements, shareholder list, inventory list, open sales orders. Basically everything. 

Obviously, the M&A process has much more nuance that outlined here, but these core steps do capture several musts in the preparation process. If you are going through the prep stage as a seller and have omitted any of these, I encourage you to take a beat and reconsider. If you are a buyer and get the sense the seller hasn’t undertook these, I would ask why. If you are on the sidelines and get the sense a competitor or colleague is taking these steps, it could be a sign they are preparing to sell.

Zachary Perge
Chief Strategy Officer
Zachary Perge is Chief Strategy Office at HARDI, joining in 2021. Prior to HARDI, Zachary worked for Deloitte Consulting in the Mergers and Acquisitions Division and has over a decade of marketing, sales, and finance experience with global consumer companies. He has an undergraduate degree in Management from Miami University and an MBA from Indiana University.
Areas of Expertise
  • Strategy
  • Profitability
  • Mergers & Acquisitions
  • Economic Outlook
2026-11-04 website-ad hardi 9pm-two-frames 300x250 v4 draftNew Platform - HARDI - November 2026
HARDI