Market Intelligence
June 1, 2021 | 5 minute read
If you’ve flipped on the TV or looked at business headlines in the last month, you’ve no doubt been greeted by reports of widespread labor shortages. Story after story documents the struggle businesses have had finding workers, as well as the great lengths some companies have gone just to convince people to come in for an interview. HARDI members too have reported challenges in finding workers, with the total number of employed production and nonsupervisory workers still lagging March 2020 totals by 3 percent.[1]
As a consequence of the labor issues, groups like the U.S. Chamber of Commerce have advocated eliminating the $300/week federal unemployment supplement before its September 6th expiration, and at least 24 states have announced plans to stop providing the federal supplement. But will opting out of the federal program fix the labor shortage issue, as many seem to think it will? Undoubtedly there are people who have chosen not to work because they earn more through unemployment benefits than they would through employment. However, recent survey results from the Census Bureau show that for most unemployed Americans, the choice not to work is more complicated than a simple assessment of where earnings will be highest.
28 percent of respondents to the Census’ most recent Household Pulse Survey selected “other reason” to the question of why they weren’t working, and an additional 10 percent reported that they simply did not want to be employed at this time. Yet 58 percent of respondents selected an option that does not include or imply that they earn more through unemployment benefits than at work. Of that 58 percent, 30 percent are not working for reasons directly related to the pandemic, and another 12 percent are not working so that they can care for children not in school or daycare.
But what if for argument’s sake we still assume that the federal unemployment supplement is the principal reason for the labor shortage? Unfortunately, even if eliminating the $300/week benefit pushed all 9 million unemployed Americans back to work, labor market challenges would persist for months (and likely years) into the future. Nearly 4 million people have left the labor force since last February, and as a result there are now just 1.2 unemployed workers per job opening in the U.S.[2] Since 2000, as the chart below shows, a ratio of roughly 1 unemployed person per job opening in the U.S. corresponds with an unemployment rate of around 4 percent – not the 6 percent level we find ourselves at today.
To put it plainly, there are fewer people looking for work than we would expect based on the number of U.S. job openings, which will put businesses in an indefinite bind to remain productive. Despite the massive improvement in labor markets since April of last year, the U.S. labor force participation rate still sits at 61.7 percent – lower than any previous period since 1977 (excluding the Covid crisis). Sadly, for this problem there is no obvious immediate fix. Historically, the only remedy for low labor force participation is sustained economic growth and a business climate attractive enough to draw people into the workforce. But, as the chart below shows, not even the longest economic expansion in U.S. history – from June 2009 to February 2020 – was enough to pull the labor force participation rate above its pre-Great Recession levels. As a result, the likelihood of a quick rebound from our current labor force challenges appears slim.
What then can HARDI members do to stay competitive in a labor constrained environment? They can and should do whatever possible to make HVACR manufacturing and distribution as attractive as possible to job seekers. HVACR distributor companies have compensated their employees well over time, and hourly wages in the sector have consistently outperformed other industrial distribution segments.
Lately, however, HVACR distribution wages have been trending downward. While still higher than the private sector average ($25.39 for HVACR distributors vs $25.25 for the overall private sector), they lag the wholesale distribution average by nearly $2.00. To offset this recent downward trend and ensure that HVACR distributor companies can better attract and retain talent, we encourage all members to review their current compensation and benefit packages. Our 2020 Compensation Survey Report can help in this process, as it offers the most complete, accurate, and up-to-date compensation and benefits data available for distributor companies. Likewise, HARDI offers an array of talent management programs and services that can help prepare your business to meet the post-Covid workforce challenges. Ultimately, the road back to a healthy labor market will be long and winding, but with the right preparation and research HARDI members can effectively meet and overcome the challenges to come.
Please contact Tim Fisher or Brian Loftus with questions or for more information about our Compensation Survey Report.
[1] Production and nonsupervisory workers are defined as workers who are not owners,
or who are not primarily employed to direct, supervise, or plan the work of
others.
[2] A person must be working or actively looking for work to be counted as part of the labor force.
