Market Intelligence
March 10, 2023 | 4 minute read

Dear HARDI Members.
An adage popular with financial market participants is “don’t fight the Fed.” That means any strategy that differs from the Fed’s objective is futile. If the Fed wants to support the economy with lower interest rates after more than 20 million of our friends and neighbors lost their jobs in the spring of 2020, then mortgage rates can drop to 3%. If the Fed wants to defeat inflation by slowing the economy, then don’t be surprised when mortgage rates double in less than a year. Father time is undefeated, and the Fed’s record is almost as good. What does that mean for us?
The housing market [see pages 13 and 14 of the full HARDInomics report] is suffering and HVAC equipment demand will follow [page 21]. Non-Residential activity [pages 15 and 16] has not yet started to turn, but that is usually a late cycle event so the 2024 forecast is as expected. There are other signs that the Fed has a fight on its hands.
Employment [page 9] growth has been stubborn. We probably need monthly gains to shrink to 100K or less, and maybe even decline, for the Fed to seriously consider a pause to their tightening [page 7] that is pushing us towards the edge of the recession cliff. The lack of layoffs [page 12] and 3.4% unemployment sound like the beginning of a tightening cycle, not eleven months after the first of eight rate increases. Employment growth is driven by the persistent demand for services that is offsetting softer demand for goods [page 4]. Industrial production [page 6] has responded but is weathering the higher interest rate headwind. The warmer than normal winter in Europe means demand from there, along with China’s reopening, will add some pep to those end markets during the months ahead and buttress the demand for labor.
The stock market gets a lot of press coverage, but the bond market [page 7] provides much better insight into the economic outlook. Inflation rates [page 7] have peaked. That has allowed mortgage rates to mark the upper edge of the new normal range. The Fed’s actions during the spring will influence the lower edge of the new normal mortgage rate of range. If inflation rates hold onto the 4-handle, then the Fed Funds rate will continue to tick higher. Dr. Anirban Basu describes this unusual dynamic of stronger economic news increasing the likelihood of a recession because it means the Fed will continue to increase the Fed Funds Rate. Don’t fight the Fed.
Another adage to avoid is “this time is different.” After relenting to thoughts of “this time is different,” Charlie Brown would learn it was not – Lucy always moved the football. We may be headed towards a recession because of the Fed Funds Rate increases and the yield curve is inverted [page 8], but this time is different! There was a pandemic. It was the shortest recession in history. Goods demand increased during a recession instead of causing a recession by decreasing. We had the quickest snapback of employment in history. Everything about this time has been different, except for the Fed, and the Fed wants inflation moving towards 2%.
If the Fed Funds rate and interest rates in general continue to increase, then the duration of softer demand HARDI members will experience this year will be extended. We need to see the inflation rates [page 8] continue to decline. An important step that could inspire a pause would be if consumer’s inflation expectations declined, but that ticked up to 4.2% in the latest University of Michigan survey from 3.9%. News like that will keep the brakes on at the Fed, weigh on the LEI, and inspire more gloomy forecasts. The war in Ukraine continues to be a potential source of disruption and the cracks in our debt ceiling mean that could fall on us. Softer demand this year is certain. There are many risks that could aggravate this dip, but growth has been stubbornly persistent, so a soft landing is still possible. The most interesting number to watch this year will be the direction of 2024 GDP estimate changes [page 5] because that will indicate which side is winning this debate and hint at how long this softer demand for our goods will persist.
Contact Brian Loftus if you're interested in participating.
