Market Intelligence
March 17, 2021 | 3 minute read
HARDI has been active in recent months sharing information on the additional $54.3 billion in funds directed to primary and secondary schools through the Elementary and Secondary School Emergency Relief Fund(ESSER). ESSER Funds are eligible to be used for HVAC upgrades in schools, but HVAC system upgrades are just one of several allowable uses for the funds. In other words, just because the funds can go to HVAC doesn’t mean they will. With that in mind, which regions are most likely to see HVAC upgrade demand?
Data from the 2012 Commercial Buildings Energy Consumption Survey (CBECS) offer a great window into the state of HVAC systems in K-12 buildings nationally, along with the estimated number of school buildings (and their total square footage) in each region of the country. To get a sense for the HVAC upgrade opportunity in each region of the country, we add the amount of ESSER funds going to each region of the country, and layer in CBECS data showing the number of schools, total square footage, and school HVAC equipment history. We use Census regions here to match how the CBECS data are reported:
CBECS data allows us to estimate the total square footage heated and cooled in U.S. primary and secondary schools. The data also allows us to estimate the number of buildings that have had HVAC equipment upgrades since 1990 (or were built after 1990). By subtracting the K-12 school square footage heated/cooled by equipment upgraded since 1990 from the total square footage heated/cooled, we can get a rough sense of the total square footage in each region that is heated/cooled by equipment in need of an upgrade.
The chart above shows our estimated school HVAC upgrade opportunity, by Census region (the New England and Middle Atlantic regions were combined to account for limited school data in the New England region). The vertical axis, which shows the number of ESSER dollars per school building, is simply the total amount of ESSER dollars available to each region divided by the number of schools in each region. The horizontal axis is the square footage in each region heated/cooled by equipment in need of upgrade, divided by the number of schools in each region.
With big, aging schools in need of HVAC upgrades (and nearly 3X the amount of funds available per school as the next closest region), the combined New England and Middle Atlantic regions offer the most potential HVAC upgrade demand in the US. The East North Central region (OH, MI, IN, IL, WI) has the greatest need per building square foot for HVAC upgrades, but each school in the region will receive ~$900,000 less than each school in the combined New England and Middle Atlantic region. While there will undoubtedly be variation on a sub-regional level, HARDI members in the New England and Middle Atlantic region should generally expect more phone calls from schools than their friends in other parts of the country.
This article was featured in our monthly Data Driven Newsletter. If you would like to receive these monthly emails, click here to sign up.
If you have any questions, or would like to suggest a featured topic for next month's DDN, contact Brian Loftus at bloftus@hardinet.org.
