Advocacy

1/25/22 Update: Vaccine Mandate Withdrawn by OSHA Following Supreme Court Action

January 25, 2022 | 8 minute read

Update 6:

OSHA withdrew the Emergency Temporary Standard (ETS) requiring employers with more than 100 employees from requiring workers to either become vaccinated or submit to weekly testing. OSHA is taking this action after the Supreme Court suspended the ETS from being implemented. This means OSHA has no enforceable mechanism to require employers to keep records of employee vaccinations or implement vaccination or testing practices. 

While OSHA withdrew the ETS as an enforceable standard, it did leave the contents of the ETS in place as a proposed rule with a notice and comment period. As a proposed rule the requirements of the ETS could come back as a regulation in the future. Using a withdrawn ETS as a proposed rule is far from the regular method of proposing a regulation and could hinder the agency’s attempt at finalizing the regulation in the future.

Update 5:

This afternoon the Supreme Court stayed the OSHA Emergency Temporary Standard on employee vaccination and testing. This ruling suspends the currently in-place requirement for employers to gather vaccination data on employees and prevents the vaccinated or test requirement that was scheduled to go in place on February 15 from going into effect. 

Because of this decision by the Supreme Court, we are likely to have some predictability in the short term as no court can undo the suspension. The Supreme Court decided to send the case back to the lower courts for a decision, it is likely the case will end up back in the Supreme Court in the future. Until the lower court makes a final decision no record keeping or testing requirements are in place.

Update 4:

On Friday night the 6th Circuit Court reinstated the Biden Administration’s employer vaccine mandate. This mandate, operated through an OSHA Emergency Temporary Standard (ETS), requires all employers with more than 100 employees, regardless of employee status as part time, full time, in-person, telework, or at various locations, to implement a vaccine or testing requirement. The 6th Circuit has not yet ruled on the constitutionality of the rule; however, they did re-instate the rule nationwide until the court can make a final ruling. No matter the outcome of that ruling, the case is likely to go to the Supreme Court for additional requests to stay the ETS and final judgement.  

Due to the previous pause in the rule, OSHA has delayed enforcement of the recordkeeping parts of the ETS until January 10, 2022, and no enforcement of the testing requirements until February 9, 2022. This non-enforcement will apply to any company making “reasonable, good faith efforts to come into compliance with the standard.” Under this delayed enforcement, businesses have until January 10, 2022, to collect vaccination status on all employees including teleworkers and maintain up-to-date records on employees’ vaccination status. Employers will then have until February 9, 2022, to implement a requirement that all employees get vaccinated or submit to weekly testing. The testing requirement will not apply to teleworkers unless they come into the office/facility and must be tested prior to coming in. 

Read more about the ETS requirements below.

Update 3:

In addition to the nationwide employer mandate being suspended by the courts, a judge with Southern District of Georgia has issued a nationwide injunction stopping enforcement of the federal contractor vaccine mandate. The mandate was previously stayed in Ohio, Kentucky, and Tennessee. With this injunction both the employer and contractor mandates are now suspended.

Update 2 (See Update 4 for Latest Information):

A federal judge has partially suspended the federal contractor vaccine mandate. This partial suspension only applies to contractors in Kentucky, Ohio, and Tennessee. The judge ruled the federal contractor mandate likely exceeded President Biden’s authority over procurement by the federal government. If additional courts block the rule in a similar fashion the suspension could become nationwide. 

Additionally, due to the nationwide judicial stay on the employer vaccine mandate, OSHA has announced they will suspend enforcement of the ETS until the court process is finalized. If the stay is lifted, OSHA will likely move quickly to enforce the rule.

Update:

Since the OSHA ETS was released last week 26 states, and multiple trade associations and businesses have filed lawsuits to oppose the vaccine mandate. So far cases have been filed in the Fifth, Sixth, Eighth, and Eleventh Circuits and requests for stays have also been filed in the Seventh and D.C. Circuit courts. Because multiple circuit courts have received petitions, these petitions will be consolidated into a single case and a lottery is used to determine which circuit court will decide the case. The Fifth Circuit enacted a stay last weekend, however the circuit court that will hear the case can overturn the stay if it does not find the stay is necessary, the Fifth Circuit can also lift the stay prior to the decision on which circuit will hear the case based on the response from the government. 

The National Association of Wholesaler-Distributors (NAW) has joined a lawsuit with a group of trade associations on behalf of the wholesale community. NAW’s lawsuit will be included in the same case as states, businesses, and other trade associations.  

As long as the case is still active, the mandate could return at any time and many legal experts are encouraging businesses to be prepared for the mandate to return and the associated record keeping requirements must be up to date if the stay is lifted after the December 5th record keeping deadline.


Original Post:

The Occupational Safety and Health Administration has released an employer vaccine mandate through an emergency temporary standard (ETS). This ETS requires workers at firms with more than 100 full or part-time workers to either become vaccinated by January 4, 2022 or get tested for coronavirus weekly. The vaccine or testing requirement only applies to employees that are required to be present for work including off-site locations such as jobsites. Teleworkers are not required to meet this vaccination or testing requirement however teleworkers do count for the 100-worker threshold. This ETS is also considered a minimum requirement by OSHA and while employers are allowed to use more stringent requirements, those additional requirements are subject to employee’s rights and NLRB oversight.

Worker choice:

The ETS allows workers to choose to either receive the vaccine or be tested weekly for every week they are in the office and within 7 days before returning to the office if they are away from the office for longer than a week. Workers who primarily work in customer homes and not in the employer office are still considered in-office workers for the vaccine or testing requirement. 

Vaccine requirements:

While the requirement is on the workers to get vaccinated or tested, each employer of a covered firm must “Develop, implement, and enforce a mandatory COVID-19 vaccination policy, with an exception for employers that instead establish, implement, and enforce a policy allowing employees to elect either to get vaccinated or to undergo weekly COVID-19 testing and wear a face covering at the workplace.” Sample policies are linked below from OSHA.

Employers will also be required to determine the vaccination status of each employee and obtain proof of vaccination and maintain records of each employee’s status. In order to facilitate vaccination, employers are also required to provide paid time off of up to four hours to get each dose of the vaccine and allow for paid sick time to recover from any side effects.  

Testing requirements:

For employees that choose to be tested the employer must ensure they are tested weekly, and employees must provide notice to the employer if they receive a positive test result or are diagnosed with coronavirus. Any employee, regardless of vaccine status, must be removed from the workplace immediately if they test positive or are diagnosed with coronavirus. 

Masking requirements:

Regardless of local mask rules or prohibitions, any unvaccinated employee will be required to wear masks or face covering while indoors or inside a vehicle with another person. 

Reporting requirements:

Employers are required to report work-related coronavirus deaths and hospitalizations to OSHA. Any fatalities must be reported within 8-hours and hospitalizations within 24 hours of the employer learning about it. Additionally records of individual employees must be available for examination and copying by the employee or their representative. 

Timeline:

Employer provisions such as recordkeeping will need to start on December 5 (30 days after being published in the Federal Register). The deadline for employers implementing testing requirements and the deadline for vaccination to avoid testing will be January 4, 2022.

State laws:

The OSHA ETS pre-empts state and local laws including prohibitions on mandates. OSHA is performing this ETS under the Occupational Safety and Health Act which allows OSHA to pre-empt state laws when a hazard to employees is present. 

It is important to note that this ETS only covers employees, not the general public that could be in the workplace or any state laws or mandates affecting their masking or vaccination. 

Federal contractors:

The deadline for federal contractors to be fully vaccinated has been pushed back to January 4, 2022, to match the employer mandate and any workers who are subject to the federal contractor vaccine requirements are exempt from the OSHA ETS requirements. The vaccine requirements for federal contractors do not include deliveries to federal facilities, only apply to workers present for continued work at the location.


Additional information:

OSHA’s two-page factsheet of the ETS is available here.
OSHA’s FAQ is available here.
Additional information including authority and state laws from OSHA available here.
Sample Vaccination, Testing, and Face Covering Policy
Sample Mandatory Vaccination Policy from OSHA.

Alex Ayers
Vice President of Government Affairs
Alex is HARDI’s lead lobbyist and regulatory expert, with over a decade of experience in Washington, DC. A former Iowa caucus delegate, he built early roots in grassroots politics. He has lobbied, published, and testified on taxes, energy, environment, agriculture, and economics. His work has been cited by the Wall Street Journal, Forbes, and the Tax Foundation.
Areas of Expertise
  • HVACR Policy
  • Government Affairs
  • Political Policy
2026-11-04 website-ad hardi 9pm-two-frames 300x250 v4 draftNew Platform - HARDI - November 2026
HARDI