Advocacy

HARDI Submits Comments to DOE Opposing Repeal of Furnace Feature Rule

October 13, 2021 | 2 minute read

HARDI has submitted comments to the Department of Energy opposing their proposed rollback of a Trump era rule that protected non-condensing technology and its associated venting as a feature for furnaces and water heaters. While HARDI supports the energy efficiency gains found in condensing furnace technology, elevating efficiency standards for all furnace sales to a level that bans the use of non-condensing furnaces will have a negative impact on some consumers. HARDI believes that consumers in existing buildings that would face new venting requirements if they were forced to install a condensing furnace would face greater economic harm than benefits from the energy efficiency gain.

The DOE proposed interpretative rule would have redefined how the Department determines “utility” of equipment. DOE’s previous definition was based around physical interaction with the equipment. DOE’s example is the window in an oven, if banned to make the door more efficient at holding heat, would in the end force the consumer to open the door to check on the food and release more heat than lost by the window. While the definition of utility works for equipment in which the consumer directly interacts, this definition does not work for HVAC equipment which is a hidden good, consumers don’t think about their interaction with the good until it doesn’t work, however forcing a consumer to adjust their living space to allow new venting, or adding new condensate mitigation devices are more likely to cause consumers to realize a negative utility to the new equipment.  

If the DOE finalizes this proposed interpretive rule, the Department will likely move forward with re-proposing a furnace rule similar to the Obama era proposed rule that would increase minimum furnace efficiency to 92%. The Obama era rule was not finalized before inauguration day in 2017 and was withdrawn by the Trump DOE. 

Alex Ayers
Vice President of Government Affairs
Alex is HARDI’s lead lobbyist and regulatory expert, with over a decade of experience in Washington, DC. A former Iowa caucus delegate, he built early roots in grassroots politics. He has lobbied, published, and testified on taxes, energy, environment, agriculture, and economics. His work has been cited by the Wall Street Journal, Forbes, and the Tax Foundation.
Areas of Expertise
  • HVACR Policy
  • Government Affairs
  • Political Policy
2026-11-04 website-ad hardi 9pm-two-frames 300x250 v4 draftNew Platform - HARDI - November 2026
HARDI