Advocacy

American Gas Association Lawsuit Over DOE Condensing Furnace Rule

October 9, 2024 | 2 minute read

The American Gas Association (AGA), American Public Gas Association, National Propane Gas Association, and a group of gas utilities filed a lawsuit against the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) over a series of rules finalized in 2023. AGA et al. argue that the Department has exceeded its statutory authority by finalizing rules that ban non-condensing technology in furnaces and commercial water heaters. This lawsuit is scheduled to go before a three-judge panel from the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia on November 21, 2024; the panelists will be announced four weeks before the oral arguments.

AGA and its co-petitioners argue that the DOE's rules violate the Energy Policy and Conservation Act (EPCA) because they would result in the unavailability of noncondensing gas-fired appliances. EPCA protects appliances with unique performance characteristics; for furnaces and commercial water heaters, the ability to use existing unpowered, vertical venting systems would meet this performance characteristic, according to the petitioners.

DOE and AGA disagree on how the Department is allowed to determine unique performance characteristics. DOE argues that only unique characteristics that are basic to the functioning of the equipment qualify, such as burning gas to produce heat, and that auxiliary characteristics like venting style are not protected. AGA responds with the argument that changes to existing structures to accommodate condensing furnaces and commercial water heaters reduce the utility of the appliance to the consumer.

Additionally, AGA argues that the DOE's economic justification for the new standards is flawed. They assert that the DOE's use of random assignment and assumptions regarding fuel-switching inflate the rule's estimated benefits and fail to accurately reflect the actual costs consumers would incur.

HARDI will continue to follow the lawsuit and provide updates. A final decision on the case is unlikely until mid-2025.


HARDI's Legal Fund

HARDI's government affairs team is looking for ways to expand how the association can use the legal fund to advance an agenda that helps our members succeed. One way is to participate in lawsuits fighting back on agency overreach. Your donations ensure we have the resources to continue to fight for your businesses in the future.

Alex Ayers
Vice President of Government Affairs
Alex is HARDI’s lead lobbyist and regulatory expert, with over a decade of experience in Washington, DC. A former Iowa caucus delegate, he built early roots in grassroots politics. He has lobbied, published, and testified on taxes, energy, environment, agriculture, and economics. His work has been cited by the Wall Street Journal, Forbes, and the Tax Foundation.
Areas of Expertise
  • HVACR Policy
  • Government Affairs
  • Political Policy
2026-11-04 website-ad hardi 9pm-two-frames 300x250 v4 draftNew Platform - HARDI - November 2026
HARDI
American Gas Association Lawsuit Over DOE Condensing Furnace Rule